Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'General My Little Pony Discussion' started by Loganberry, 6 December 2015.
That's what I said originally, you disagreed and said all alicorns were the same, so which is it?
I didn't disagree with you. The only thing I said was
That having royal blood does not instantly mean Alicorn.
Except we don't know that, at all.
It's highly unlikely Tia or Luna ever actually had children, Tia in particular seems to adopt and call them her nephews and nieces but they don't seem to be blood relations to her.
Luna was too young and wouldn't have had a chance. Twilight even more so, this might actually be the first Alicorn mating for all we know. They might all produce them as long as one parent is one.
Well we kinda do with Twilight, she doesn't have any royal blood, yet she became an Alicorn. Which to me says that if you want to become a Modern Alicorn, then Celestia or Luna have to make that decision.
We don't even know how they do that, or who showed them how, or if Luna can do it. Or if there are others out there. There is next to no Alicorn canon at all except that there are two kinds, two apparently born, two made. And that when they mate, they make more.
But why do all the characters look shocked about this, especially the parents in the teaser. Even Celestia and Luna don't look happy about this.
As it would seem none of them have ever had children to know what happens, now they do, and they're surprised.
But you would think that the "Gods" of the world would know how Alicorn biology works, I mean after all Celestia and Luna were children once as well, as established in a previous episode.
Even Twilight would know about this, since she is a study troll.
We've seen no indication anything exists beyond the creatures in Equestria and surronding lands. And Twilight mentioned she could find nothing on Alicorns in her studies shortly after becoming one, Rarity doesn't even know another pony can be made one, having met Cadance. There is nothing written down on them, as only Tia and Luna existed until ~30 years ago and they don't seem to have written anything down for anyone.
As far as the show is concerned, even Tia and Luna look to not know where they came from or have met their own parents, but they were born to someone at some point. And there is no "Alicorn manual", rules, knowledge or lore. We're finding out along with them.
I guess you didn't see the brackets and the S letter.
As far as the show is concerned, even Tia and Luna look to not know where they came from or have met their own parents, but they were born to someone at some point. And there is no "Alicorn manual", rules, knowledge or lore.
So what about Cadence then, did ponies just ignore her birth then? And not record anything? That was very rude of them.
Or Celestia kept it secret. But in the two years since her ascension, Twilight has never mentioned any lore on Alicorns, there doesn't seem to be any. So as far as it goes, there are no rules.
I just had a glorious thought.
Could this possibly lead to some Tia & Woona flashbacks?
I hope so.
Only If Celestia kept things secret. Which honestly I can't see why she would. I mean why would she allow Cadence's marriage if something like this was going to happen. The only way I can see it as is this....
Celestia: You said it was going to be a pure marriage!
Cadence: I know, but the atmosphere, him, and oh you just had to be there.
Celestia: Well great the world is probably going to get screwed again, because you failed to follow one rule. ONE RULE!!!"
Considering what Pound and Pumpkin Cake were capable of....
So what power do you think this new princess will have? Maybe the power of who lives and who dies?
Playing with the moon like a rubber ball, throwing it around. This should be fun.
Based purely on her name, I'd say: Snowstorms that cause fatal heart attacks